Mathematics 8 Quarter 2 Module 14: Writing Proofs (Direct and Indirect)

Grade 8 Math Q2 Module 14 teaches how to define, compare, and write direct and indirect proofs in two-column form, with examples and an answer key.

This is the Grade 8 Mathematics Quarter 2 Module 14 self-learning module, “Writing Proofs (Direct and Indirect).” It was developed by DepEd Caraga Region (First Edition, 2020) for home-based learning. It has one lesson. After it, learners should be able to explain the two main ways of proving a mathematical statement and write each kind of proof in two-column form.

On this page 8 sections

What learners will learn

After going through this module, learners are expected to:

  1. define direct proof and indirect proof;
  2. differentiate a direct proof from an indirect proof; and
  3. write direct proof and indirect proof.

Lesson in this module

  • Lesson 1: Writing Direct Proof and Indirect Proof. This lesson uses what learners already know about the properties of equality and inequality, congruence, and the definitions and postulates of Geometry. Learners then use these to build both types of proof.

Tools you need for writing proofs

The module first reviews the facts that serve as reasons in a proof. For real numbers a, b, and c:

Property of EqualityStatement
Reflexivea = a
SymmetricIf a = b, then b = a.
TransitiveIf a = b and b = c, then a = c.
AdditionIf a = b, then a + c = b + c.
SubtractionIf a = b, then a − c = b − c.
MultiplicationIf a = b, then ac = bc.
DivisionIf a = b and c ≠ 0, then a/c = b/c.

The module also lists the properties of inequality. For example, multiplying or dividing both sides by a negative number reverses the inequality sign. It also gives two postulates:

  • Segment Addition Postulate: AB + BC = AC
  • Angle Addition Postulate: ∠ABD + ∠DBC = ∠ABC

A proof is a logical argument in which every statement is supported by given information, definitions, axioms, postulates, theorems, or statements already proven. The module separates three terms:

  • An axiom is a statement that serves as a starting point from which other points are derived.
  • A postulate is a statement accepted without proof.
  • A theorem is a statement accepted after it is proved deductively.

Direct proof

A direct proof uses accepted facts to reason step by step until the desired statement is reached. Its steps are:

  1. Assume the statement p is true.
  2. Use what you know about p, and other facts, to deduce that statement q is true. This shows that p → q (if p, then q) is true.

Proofs in the module are written in two-column form, with one column for statements and one for reasons.

Example from the module: If 2(3x + 4) = 56, then x = 8.

StatementsReasons
1. 2(3x + 4) = 56Given
2. 2(3x) + 2(4) = 56Distributive Property
3. 6x + 8 = 56Simplification
4. 6x + 8 − 8 = 56 − 8Subtraction Property of Equality
5. 6x = 48Simplification
6. 6x/6 = 48/6Division Property of Equality
7. x = 8Simplification

A second example proves that if AB = CD on a line with points A, B, C, D in order, then AC = BD. It uses the Reflexive Property (BC = BC), the Addition Property, the Segment Addition Postulate, and substitution.

Indirect proof

An indirect proof works differently. You first assume that the statement to be proved is false. If that assumption leads to an impossibility, the statement must be true. Its steps are:

  1. Identify the statement you want to prove. Assume for now that it is false, by assuming its opposite is true.
  2. Reason logically until you reach a contradiction.
  3. Point out that the desired conclusion must be true, because the contradiction shows the temporary assumption is false.

Example from the module: If x = 2, then 3x − 4 ≠ 8.

  • Start by assuming the opposite: 3x − 4 = 8.
  • Add 4 to both sides: 3x = 12.
  • Multiply both sides by 1/3: x = 4.
  • But x = 4 contradicts the given fact that x = 2. So the assumption is false, and 3x − 4 ≠ 8 is true.

A geometry example uses the same idea. It is given that ray ED is not perpendicular to ray EF, and the task is to prove that ∠1 and ∠2 are not complementary.

  • Assume the angles are complementary, so their measures add up to 90.
  • By the Angle Addition Postulate, that makes ∠DEF a right angle.
  • A right angle would make ED perpendicular to EF, which contradicts the given.

In short, a direct proof moves forward from the given to the conclusion. An indirect proof starts from the opposite of the conclusion and looks for a contradiction.

How to use this module

The module is arranged in parts that should be done in order:

  1. What I Know: a 15-item pre-assessment to check what you already know.
  2. What’s In: “Equality Express,” a fill-in-the-blank review of the properties of equality.
  3. What’s New: “Prove Me Right!”, which compares two proofs of the same statement (if 3x + 6 = 18, then x = 4).
  4. What is It: the discussion and worked examples.
  5. What’s More: three practice activities:
    • “I Need Proof!”: complete a direct proof.
    • “Prove Me Indirectly!”: arrange the steps of an indirect proof.
    • “I Like to Prove It! Prove It!”: write a proof using either method.
  6. What I Have Learned: sort the steps into direct proof and indirect proof.
  7. What I Can Do: agree or disagree with a statement about following COVID-19 health protocols, and justify your answer with proofs. A 0-to-4 rubric is used for scoring.
  8. Assessment: a 15-item post-assessment, followed by an Additional Activity about distances between rooms along a school hallway.

For learners: write all answers on a separate sheet of paper and do not mark the module. Check your work honestly using the answer key at the end.

For parents: help your child follow the parts in order. Contact the teacher if your child gets stuck.

For teachers: the answer key covers the pre- and post-assessments and the practice activities. The “What I Can Do” task and the Additional Activity have answers that may vary, so use the rubric for those.

Frequently asked questions

What grade and quarter is this Writing Proofs module for?

It is for Grade 8 Mathematics, Quarter 2. It is Module 14 and has one lesson, Writing Direct Proof and Indirect Proof.

What is the difference between a direct proof and an indirect proof?

A direct proof assumes the hypothesis is true and reasons step by step with accepted facts until it reaches the conclusion. An indirect proof assumes the conclusion is false, reasons until it reaches a contradiction, and so shows the conclusion must be true.

What is the first step of an indirect proof?

Identify the statement you want to prove and temporarily assume it is false, by assuming its opposite is true. For example, to prove 3x − 4 ≠ 8, you start by assuming 3x − 4 = 8.

What is a two-column proof?

It is a way of organizing a proof in two columns, one for the statements and one for the reasons that justify each statement.

Does the module have an answer key?

Yes. It includes answers for the pre-assessment, the review activity, the practice activities, What I Have Learned, and the post-assessment. Answers to the performance task and the additional activity may vary.

Full text of the module

The text below is a transcription of the PDF above, as printed.

8

Mathematics Quarter 2 – Module 14: “Writing Proofs (Direct and Indirect)”

[illustration: students studying outdoors and indoors, a teacher at a desk, and a globe]

CO_Q2_Mathematics8_ M14

Mathematics– Grade 8 Alternative Delivery Mode Quarter 2– Module 14: Writing Proofs (Direct and Indirect) First Edition, 2020

Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things, impose as a condition the payment of royalties.

Borrowed materials (i.e., songs, stories, poems, pictures, photos, brand names, trademarks, etc.) included in this book are owned by their respective copyright holders. Every effort has been exerted to locate and seek permission to use these materials from their respective copyright owners. The publisher and authors do not represent nor claim ownership over them.

Published by the Department of Education Secretary: Leonor Magtolis Briones Undersecretary: Diosdado M. San Antonio

Development Team of the Module

Writers: Rizza Mae S. Bagsican Language Editor: Vicente P. Balbuena Content Editor: Riza C. Cadavos, Joselito C. Serna, Cecille C. Guimary, Mary Grace R. Prado, Jessel G. Azarcon Layout Editor: Jay R. Tinambacan Reviewers: Rhodora C. Luga, Charlie May C. Octal, Irelle B. Tesado, Mellanie G. Tuyor, Keziah Grace B. Presto Illustrator: Rizza Mae S. Bagsican Layout Artist: Rizza Mae S. Bagsican, Leonil Rechie P. Cahanap Management Team: Francis Cesar B. Bringas, Isidro M. Biol, Jr., Rhea J. Yparraguirre, Maripaz F. Magno, Josephine Chonie M. Obseñares, Josita B. Carmen, Celsa A. Casa, Regina Euann A. Puerto, Bryan L. Arreo, Leopardo P. Cortes, Claire Ann P. Gonzaga, Lieu Gee Keeshia C. Guillen

Printed in the Philippines by ________________________

Department of Education – Caraga Region

Office Address: Learning Resource Management Section (LRMS), J.P. Rosales Avenue, Butuan City, Philippines 8600 Telefax No.: (085) 342-8207 / (085) 342-5969 E-mail Address: caraga@deped.gov.ph

8

Mathematics Quarter 2 – Module 14: “Writing Proofs (Direct and Indirect)”

Introductory Message

This Self-Learning Module (SLM) is prepared so that you, our dear learners, can continue your studies and learn while at home. Activities, questions, directions, exercises, and discussions are carefully stated for you to understand each lesson.

Each SLM is composed of different parts. Each part shall guide you step-by-step as you discover and understand the lesson prepared for you.

Pre-tests are provided to measure your prior knowledge on lessons in each SLM. This will tell you if you need to proceed on completing this module or if you need to ask your facilitator or your teacher’s assistance for better understanding of the lesson. At the end of each module, you need to answer the post-test to self-check your learning. Answer keys are provided for each activity and test. We trust that you will be honest in using these.

In addition to the material in the main text, Notes to the Teacher are also provided to our facilitators and parents for strategies and reminders on how they can best help you on your home-based learning.

Please use this module with care. Do not put unnecessary marks on any part of this SLM. Use a separate sheet of paper in answering the exercises and tests. And read the instructions carefully before performing each task.

If you have any questions in using this SLM or any difficulty in answering the tasks in this module, do not hesitate to consult your teacher or facilitator.

Thank you.

What I Need to Know

[illustration: hand pointing at a circle, icon beside the heading]

In this module, you will be acquainted with the different ways in writing proofs which will help sharpen your ability to provide logical reasoning about a phenomenon or a situation. The scope of this module enables you to use it in many different learning situations. The lesson is arranged to follow the standard sequence of the course. But the order in which you read them can be changed to correspond with the textbook you are now using.

This module contains:

Lesson 1- Writing Direct Proof and Indirect Proof

After going through this module, you are expected to:

  1. define direct proof and indirect proof;
  2. differentiate a direct proof from an indirect proof; and
  3. write direct proof and indirect proof.

What I Know

[illustration: hand holding a pencil, icon beside the heading]

Pre-Assessment

Directions: Choose the letter of the correct answer. Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.

  1. What is a direct proof?
    A. A proof that always involves the multiplication of two values.
    B. A proof that can only use number properties to show that a certain statement is false.
    C. A proof that assumes a statement’s hypothesis is true and uses a series of logical deductions to conclude that the statement’s conclusion is true.
    D. A proof that assumes that the statement being proven is false and then attempts to find a contradiction to that assumption proving the original statement to be true.


  2. What does an indirect proof rely on?
    A. a contradiction
    B. a function
    C. a product
    D. a sum


  3. Which of the following is NOT a difference between direct and indirect proofs?
    A. Indirect proofs look for a contradiction to their original assumption, and direct proofs do not.
    B. Direct proofs use other theorems, rules, and definitions in their proofs, and indirect proofs do not.
    C. Indirect proof usually starts with the statement ‘assume not’ or ‘assume the opposite’, and direct proofs do not.
    D. Direct proofs involve assuming a hypothesis is true, and indirect proofs involve assuming a conjecture is false.


  4. Which of the following statements is true?
    A. Start an indirect proof by assuming that the conclusion is true.
    B. Start an indirect proof by assuming that the conclusion is false.
    C. Both of these statements are true.
    D. Neither of these statements are true.


Consider the statement for numbers 5 and 6.

Prove: “𝐼𝑓 2(3𝑚 − 5) = 8, 𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑛 𝑚 = 3”.

StatementReasons
1. 2(3𝑚 − 5) = 8Given
2. 2(3𝑚) − 2(5) = 8(5)
3. 6𝑚 − 10 = 8Simplification
4. (6)Addition Property of Equality
5. 6𝑚 = 18Simplification
6. 6𝑚/6 = 18/6Division Property of Equality
7. 𝑚 = 3Simplification
  1. What is the reason for the statement 2(3𝑚) − 2(5) = 8 in Step 2?
    A. Addition Property of Equality
    B. Subtraction Property of Equality
    C. Distributive Property of Equality
    D. Transitive Property of Equality


  2. Which statement is true using Addition Property of Equality in Step 4?
    A. 6𝑚 − 10 − 8 = 8 − 8
    B. 6𝑚 − 10 + 8 = 8 + 8
    C. 6𝑚 − 10 + 10 = 8 + 10
    D. 6𝑚 − 10 − 10 = 8 − 10


Consider the statement for numbers 7 and 8.

Prove that if 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐶𝐷 and 𝐶𝐷 ≅ 𝐸𝐹, then 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐸𝐹

StatementsReasons
1. (7)Given
2. 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐶𝐷 and 𝐶𝐷 = 𝐸𝐹Definition of Congruent Segments
3. 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐸𝐹(8)
4. 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐸𝐹Definition of Congruent Segments
  1. Which statement is correct for Step 1 of the proof?
    A. 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐶𝐷
    B. 𝐶𝐷 ≅ 𝐸𝐹
    C. 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐶𝐷 and 𝐶𝐷 ≅ 𝐸𝐹
    D. 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐸𝐹 and 𝐴𝐵 ≅ 𝐶𝐷


  2. What is the reason for the statement 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐸𝐹 in Step 3 of the proof?
    A. Addition Property of Equality
    B. Distributive Property of Equality
    C. Subtraction Property of Equality
    D. Transitive Property of Equality


  3. What assumption would you make from the statement that, “There can be only one 90° angle in a triangle” using indirect proof?
    A. All the angles in a triangle add up to 90°.
    B. All the angles in a triangle add up to 180°.
    C. There can be more than one 90° angle in a triangle.
    D. There can be more than one 180° angle in a triangle.


  4. What assumption would you make from the statement that “If 3𝑥 + 7 > 13, then 𝑥 > 2″ using indirect proof?
    A. 𝑥 ≤ 2
    B. 𝑥 < 2
    C. 𝑥 ≥ 2
    D. 𝑥 = 2


  5. What is the first step of an indirect proof?
    A. Write the given.
    B. Contradict the given.
    C. Assume the negation of the given.
    D. Assume the negation of what you are trying to prove.


  6. If you were proving that a given line 𝑙, is perpendicular to another line 𝑗, using indirect proof, what would your initial assumption be?
    A. Assume that line 𝑙 is not perpendicular to line 𝑗.
    B. Assume that line 𝑙 is perpendicular to line 𝑗.
    C. Assume that line 𝑙 and line 𝑗 are parallel.
    D. None of these are correct.


  7. Which is a contradiction to the statement 𝑋𝑌 ≅ 𝑅𝑇?
    A. 𝑋𝑌 < 𝑅𝑇
    B. 𝑇𝑅 ≅ 𝑌𝑋
    C. 𝑋𝑌 ≈ 𝑅𝑇
    D. 𝑋𝑌 ≤ 𝑅𝑇


  8. Given ∠𝐴 is an angle. Prove ∠𝐴 ≅ ∠𝐴. What is the reason for the statement 𝑚∠𝐴 ≅ 𝑚∠𝐴 in Step 2 of the proof?


StatementsReasons
1. ∠𝐴 is an angleGiven
2. 𝑚∠𝐴 ≅ 𝑚∠𝐴(14)
3. ∠𝐴 = ∠𝐴Definition of Congruent Angles
  1. Given ∠A ≅ ∠B and ∠B ≅ ∠C. Prove ∠A ≅ ∠C. What is the reason for the statement m∠A = m∠C in Step 3 of the proof?
StatementsReasons
1. ∠A ≅ ∠B and ∠B ≅ ∠CGiven
2. m∠A = m∠B and m∠B = m∠CDefinition of Congruent Angles
3. m∠A = m∠C(15)
4. m∠A ≅ m∠CDefinition of Congruent Angles

A. Addition Property of Equality B. Distributive Property of Equality C. Subtraction Property of Equality D. Transitive Property of Equality

Lesson 1 Writing Direct Proof and Indirect Proof

In this lesson, your previous knowledge about properties of equality and inequality, congruence, as well as definitions and postulates in Geometry will be put to test as these are necessary information in making proofs.

[illustration: hand holding puzzle pieces]

What’s In
Activity: Equality Express

Directions: To illustrate each of the given property, fill in the blanks with the correct number to complete the following mathematical statements. Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.

Properties of EqualityStatements
1. Addition Property of Equality →If 3 + 2 = 5, then (3 + 2) + 4 = 5 + ___
2. Subtraction Property of Equality →If 5 + 1 = 6, then (5 + 1) − 2 = ___ − 2
3. Multiplication Property of Equality →If (4)(___)(2) = 12(2)
4. Division Property of Equality →If (8)(2) = 16, then (8)(2) / ___ = 16 / ___
5. Transitive Property of Equality →If 7 + 5 = 12 and 12 = 10 + 2, then 7 + ___ = ___ + 2

Questions:

  1. Did you easily find the number that will make the equality true? How?
  2. How did the Properties of Equality help you in finding the missing numbers to complete the mathematical statements?
  3. Do you think that these properties will help you in writing proofs? Explain your answer.
What’s New

Knowing the validity of the hypothesis in the previous lesson about conditional statements is an important skill to form statements of proof and make generalization. Thus, you are now ready to study the types of proofs.

Activity: Prove Me Right!

Directions: Study and examine how each of the proof below presents its way of proving the given statement. Then, answer the questions that follow. Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.

Prove that if 3x + 6 = 18 then x = 4. Given: 3x + 6 = 18 Prove: x = 4

[illustration: hand holding a plant sprout in a circle]

Proof A:

StatementsReasons
1. 3x + 6 = 18Given
2. 3x + 6 − 6 = 18 − 6 / 3x = 12Subtraction Property of Equality
3. 3x / 3 = 12 / 3 / x = 4Division Property of Equality

Proof B:

Let x ≠ 4. If x ≠ 4, then x < 4 or x > 4

Situation 1: If x < 4

StatementsReasons
1. x < 4Given
2. 3x < 3(4)Multiplication Property of Equality
3. 3x < 12Simplification
4. 3x + 6 < 12 + 6Addition Property of Equality
5. 3x + 6 < 18Simplification

Notice that if x ≠ 4, then 3x + 6 < 18. Therefore, this is a contradiction to the given that 3x + 6 = 18.

Situation 2: If x > 4

StatementsReasons
1. x > 4Given
2. 3x > 3(4)Multiplication Property of Equality
3. 3x > 12Simplification
4. 3x + 6 > 12 + 6Addition Property of Equality
5. 3x + 6 > 18Simplification

Notice that if x ≠ 4, then 3x + 6 > 18. Therefore, this is a contradiction to the given that 3x + 6 = 18.

Questions:

  1. What can you say about Proof A? Proof B?
  2. Is there a difference between Proof A and Proof B? If yes, what is the difference? If no, why do you say so?
  3. Why is it important to know how to write proofs given a problem or a situation?
What is It

In the previous activity, two methods of proof were used to prove the given statement – Direct Proof and Indirect Proof. Demonstrating understanding on how to develop these proofs will be easier by considering some of the Properties of Equality, Inequality and Congruence including Postulates as cited below:

Properties of Equality

Let a, b, and c be real numbers.

PropertiesStatements
Reflexive Propertya = a
Symmetric PropertyIf a = b, then b = a.
Transitive PropertyIf a = b and b = c, then a = c.
Addition PropertyIf a = b, then a + c = b + c.
Subtraction PropertyIf a = b, then a − c = b − c.
Multiplication PropertyIf a = b, then ac = bc.
Division PropertyIf a = b and c ≠ 0, then a/c = b/c.
Properties of Inequality

Let a, b, and c be real numbers.

PropertiesStatements
Addition PropertyIf a < b, then a + c < b + c
Subtraction PropertyIf a < b, then a − c < b − c
Multiplication PropertyIf a < b, and c > 0, then ac < bc. If a > b, and c > 0, then ac > bc. If a > b, and c < 0, then ac < bc. If a < b, and c < 0, then ac > bc.
Division PropertyIf a < b and c > 0, then a/c < b/c. If a < b and c < 0, then a/c > b/c.
Postulates
PostulatesStatements
Segment Addition PostulateAB + BC = AC
Angle Addition Postulate[illustration: segment with points A, B, C in order]
[illustration: angle with rays BA, BD, and BC, with points A, B, C, D labeled] ∠ABD + ∠DBC = ∠ABC

A proof is a logical argument in which each statement you make is supported/justified by given information, definitions, axioms, postulates, theorems, and previously proven statements.

Note:

  • An axiom is any mathematical statement that serves as a starting point from which other points are logically derived.
  • A postulate is a statement that is accepted without proof.
  • A theorem is a statement accepted after it is proved deductively.

There are two methods in writing proof. These include:

  1. Direct Proof
  2. Indirect Proof

Direct proof is a type of logical reasoning that uses accepted facts to reason in a step-by-step manner until the desired statement is obtained.

Steps in writing a direct proof:

  1. Assume the statement p is true.
  2. Use what you know about p and other facts as necessary to deduce that another statement q is true, that is to show p→q (if p then q) is true.

Two-Column Form is one way of organizing a proof. This consists of two columns, one for statements and one for reasons.

Illustrative Example 1. If 2 (3x + 4) = 56, then x = 8. Given: 2 (3x + 4) = 56 Prove: x = 8

Proof:

StatementsReasons
1. 2(3x + 4) = 56Given
2. 2(3x) + 2(4) = 56Distributive Property of Equality
3. 6x + 8 = 56Simplification
4. 6x + 8 – 8 = 56 – 8Subtraction Property of Equality

transcriber’s note: table continued from the previous page

StatementsReasons
5. 6x = 48Simplification
6. 6x / 6 = 48 / 6Division Property of Equality
7. x = 8Simplification

Illustrative Example 2.

[illustration: segment with points A, B, C, D in order]

Given: AB = CD Prove: AC = BD

Proof:

StatementsReasons
1. AB = CDGiven
2. BC = BCReflexive Property
3. AB + BC = CD + BCAddition Property of Equality
4. AC = AB + BC / BD = BC + CDSegment Addition Postulate
5. AC = BDSubstitution Property

Indirect proof is a type of proof in which a statement to be proved is assumed false (by negation) and if the assumption leads to an impossibility, then the statement assumed false has been proved to be true.

Steps in writing an indirect proof:

  1. Identify the statement you want to prove. Assume temporarily that this statement is false by assuming that its opposite is true.
  2. Reasons logically until you reach a contradiction.
  3. Point out that the desired conclusion must be true because the contradiction proves the temporary assumption false.

Illustrative Example 1. If x = 2, then 3x − 4 ≠ 8. Given: x = 2 Prove: 3x − 4 ≠ 8

Proof:

StatementsReasons
1. 3x − 4 = 8Negation (Indirect proof assumption)
2. 3x − 4 + 4 = 8 + 4Addition Property of Equality
3. 3x = 12Simplification
4. 1/3 (3x) = 1/3 (12)Multiplication Property of Equality
5. x = 4Simplification

But x = 4 contradicts the given statement that x = 2. Since our assumption is false therefore, 3x − 4 ≠ 8 is true.

Illustrative Example 2. Given: ED⃗ is not perpendicular to EF⃗ Prove: ∠1 and ∠2 are not complementary

[illustration: angle DEF with ray EG between ED and EF, angles 1 and 2 marked]

Proof:

StatementsReasons
1. Suppose ∠1 and ∠2 are complementary.Indirect proof assumption
2. m∠1 + m∠2 = 90The sum of the measures of complementary angles is 90°.
3. m∠1 + m∠2 = m∠DEFAngle Addition Postulate
4. m∠DEF = 90Substitution
5. ∠DEF is a right angleDefinition of Right Angle
6. ED⃗ ⊥ EF⃗Definition of Perpendicularity

Note that statement 6 is a contradiction to the given hypothesis that ED⃗ is not perpendicular to EF⃗, hence, the assumption that ∠1 and ∠2 are complementary must be false and it follows that ∠1 and ∠2 are not complementary.

Going Back

Let us look back at the Prove Me Right Activity on page 7 where you were asked to determine the difference between the types of proof used given one statement. Considering the discussions presented, Proof A clearly illustrates direct proof since the proof uses accepted facts to reason in a step-by-step manner until the desired statement is obtained. While Proof B shows how a given statement is proved using indirect proof since the proof started with an assumption opposite to the given statement until a contradiction is reached in the process.

What’s More

[illustration: stack of blocks]

Activity 1: I Need Proof!

Directions: Fill in the blanks by choosing your answers from the box. Write it on a separate sheet of paper.

2(b + 1) = −62b + 2 = −62b/2 = −8/2
GivenProveby Simplification
Subtraction Property of EqualityAddition Property of EqualityMultiplicative Property of Equality

Prove that if 2(b + 1) = −6, then b = −4. Given: 2(b + 1) = −6 Prove: b = −4

Proof:

StatementsReasons
1. 2(b + 1) = −6
2.Distributive Property of Equality
3. 2b + 2 − 2 = −6 − 2
4. 2b = −8by Simplification
5.Division Property of Equality
6. b = −4
Activity 2: Prove Me Indirectly!

Directions: Arrange the statements to its logical order using an indirect proof. Use letters A to F. Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.

Prove that if y = −3, then 4(y − 3) ≠ −20.

_________1. 4y − 12 = −20 by distributive property of equality. _________2. Hence our assumption is false and 4(y − 3) ≠ −20 is true _________3. Using addition property of equality, 4y − 12 + 12 = −20 + 12. So 4y = −8 by simplifying. _________4. Assume that 4(y − 3) = −20. Take this statement as true and solve for y. _________5. Thus, division property of equality, 4y/4 = −8/4. So y = −2 by simplifying. _________6. But y = −2, contradicts the given statement that y = −3.

Activity 3: I Like to Prove It! Prove It!

Directions: Prove the given statement using ONLY ONE of the two methods (direct proof or indirect proof) which you find easier to use. Write your answers on separate sheet of paper.

If (1/5)(x + 10) = 3, then x = 5 Prove: (1/5)(x + 10) = 3 Given: x = 5

What I Have Learned

Directions: Given are the steps in writing proofs for both direct and indirect. Classify these steps accordingly to the type of proof.

Steps in writing Direct ProofSteps in Writing Indirect Proof
  • Assume the statement 𝑝 is true.
  • Cite the reasons logically until you reach a contradiction.
  • Point out that the desired conclusion must be true because the contradiction proves the temporary assumption false.
  • Identify the statement you want to prove. Assume temporarily that this statement is false (by negation) by assuming that its opposite is true.
  • Use what you know about 𝑝 and other facts as necessary to deduce that another statement 𝑞 is true, that is show 𝑝→𝑞 (if p then q) is true.

What I Can Do

Directions: Given the proposition “If you will follow the health protocols during COVID-19 pandemic, then you will be safe from getting infected with the virus”. Do you agree with the statement? Justify your answer by citing your proofs.

Rubric for the Written Proof
ScoreDescriptions
(4) ExemplaryA correct and complete proof is given. Some irrelevant information may be included, particularly on timed work where the student is unable to polish up the presentation.
(3) AcceptableA correct approach to proving the proposition is attempted. Some statements may be unjustified or improperly justified, but errors are minor and could be fixed without substantially changing the proof.
(2) BasicStatements linked into a reasonable (though perhaps misguided) attempt to prove the theorem. The proof may be left incomplete or may depend upon a major unjustified leap.
(1) PoorUnconnected, mostly true statements properly deduced from the given. Listing facts without a sense of how to link them to get a correct proof. May just jump to the conclusion without justification.
(0) UnacceptableMainly incorrect consequences improperly deduced from the given. Little or no sense of how to prove the result.

Assessment

Post-Assessment

Directions: Choose the letter of the correct answer. Write the chosen letter on a separate sheet of paper.

  1. What is an indirect proof?
    a. A proof that always involves the multiplication of two values.
    b. A proof that can only use number properties to show that a certain statement is false.
    c. A proof that assumes a statement’s hypothesis is true and uses a series of logical deductions to conclude that the statement’s conclusion is true
    d. A proof that assumes that the statement being proven is false and then attempts to find a contradiction to that assumption proving the original statement to be true


  2. A proof that 𝑝 → 𝑞 is true based on the fact that 𝑞 is true, such proof is known as _____.
    a. Direct Proof
    b. Indirect Proof
    c. Both A and B are correct
    d. Neither A nor B are correct


  3. Which of the following occurs with a direct proof?
    a. Statements are supported by known facts and definitions.
    b. A conditional statement is proven.
    c. A series of statements are made.
    d. All statements are correct.


  4. Which statement is NOT true?
    a. Start an indirect proof by assuming that the statement is true.
    b. Start an indirect proof by assuming that the statement is false.
    c. Use direct proof through accepted facts to reason in a step-by-step manner until the desired statement is arrived.
    d. Use two-column form to show a way of organizing a proof. This form consists of two columns, one for statements and one for reasons.


  5. What assumption would you make from the statement that 𝐴𝐵̅̅̅̅ is congruent to 𝐵𝐶̅̅̅̅ using indirect proof?
    a. 𝐴 ≠ 𝐵
    b. 𝐵 ≠ 𝐶
    c. 𝐴𝐵 ≠ 𝐵𝐶
    d. 𝐵𝐴̅̅̅̅ ≤ 𝐶𝐵̅̅̅̅


Consider the statement for your answers in numbers 6 and 7.

Given: 𝐴, 𝐵, 𝐶, and 𝐷 are collinear in that order and 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐶𝐷. Prove: 𝐴𝐶 = 𝐵𝐷

StatementsReasons
1. 𝐴, 𝐵, 𝐶, and 𝐷 are collinear, in that order.Given
2. 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐶𝐷Given
3. 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐵𝐶(6)
4. 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐵𝐶 + 𝐶𝐷Addition Property of Equality
5. 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐴𝐶
𝐵𝐶 + 𝐶𝐷 = 𝐵𝐷
(7)
6. 𝐴𝐶 = 𝐵𝐷Substitution Property
  1. What is the “reason” for the “statement” 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐵𝐶 in Step 3 of the proof?
    a. Commutative Property
    b. Reflexive Property
    c. Symmetric Property
    d. Transitive Property


  2. What is the “reason” from the “statement” 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐴𝐶, 𝐵𝐶 + 𝐶𝐷 = 𝐵𝐷 in Step 5 of the proof?
    a. Angle Addition Postulate
    b. Segment Addition Postulate
    c. Commutative Property of Equality
    d. Distributive Property of Equality


Consider the statement for your answers in numbers 8 and 9.

Prove: If 𝑦 + 4/3 = 10/3, then 𝑦 = 2

StatementReasons
1. 𝑦 + 4/3 = 10/3Given
2. 3𝑦 + 4 = 10Multiplication Property of Equality
3. (8)Subtraction Property of Equality
4. 𝑦 = 2(9)
  1. Which statement is true using Subtraction Property of Equality in Step 3?
    a. 3𝑦 + 4 − 10 = 10 − 10
    b. 3𝑦 + 4 − 4 = 10 − 4
    c. 3𝑦 + 4 + 10 = 10 + 10
    d. 3𝑦 + 4 + 4 = 10 + 4


  2. What is the reason for the statement 𝑦 = 2 in Step 4 of the proof?
    a. Addition Property of Equality
    b. Multiplication Property of Equality


    c. Subtraction Property of Equality
    d. Substitution Property


  3. What assumption would you make from the statement that △𝐴𝐵𝐶 ≅ △𝐷𝐸𝐹 using indirect proof?
    a. △𝐴𝐵𝐶 ≠ △𝐷𝐸𝐹
    b. △𝐴𝐵𝐶 ≇ △𝐷𝐸𝐹
    c. △𝐴𝐵𝐶 ≤ △𝐷𝐸𝐹
    d. △𝐴𝐵𝐶 ≥ △𝐷𝐸𝐹


Consider the statement for your answers in numbers 11 and 12.

If 𝑥 = 2, then 3𝑥 − 5 ≠ 10. Prove this statement by contradiction.

StatementsReasons
1. 3𝑥 − 5 = 10
2. 3𝑥 − 5 + 5 = 10 + 5Addition Property of Equality
3. 3𝑥 = 15by Simplification
4. 𝑥 = 5Division Property of Equality
  1. What is the reason for the statement 3𝑥 − 5 = 10 in Step 1?
    a. by Contradiction
    b. by Negation
    c. by Simplification
    d. by Substitution


  2. What concluding statement can be drawn from the proof presented?
    a. Since 𝑥 = 2 is false, therefore 3𝑥 − 5 = 10.
    b. Since 𝑥 = 2 is true, therefore 3𝑥 − 5 = 10.
    c. Since 𝑥 = 5 is false, therefore 3𝑥 − 5 ≠ 10.
    d. Since 𝑥 = 5 is true, therefore 3𝑥 − 5 ≠ 10.


For the statement in numbers 13, 14, 15.

Consider that points 𝐴, 𝐵, and 𝐶 are collinear.

Prove: If 𝐴𝐵 = 1/2 𝐴𝐶, then 𝐵 is the midpoint of 𝐴𝐶̅̅̅̅.

StatementsReasons
1. 𝐴𝐵 = 1/2 𝐴𝐶Given
2. (13)Multiplication Property of Equality
3. 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐴𝐶Substitution Property of Equality
4. 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐴𝐶(14)
5. 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶Transitive Property of Equality
6. 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐵𝐶(15)
7. 𝐵 is the midpoint of 𝐴𝐶̅̅̅̅Definition of a Midpoint
  1. Which statement is true using Multiplication Property of Equality in Step 2?
    a. 1/2 𝐴𝐶
    b. 𝐴𝐵 = 2𝐴𝐶
    c. 2𝐴𝐵 = 𝐴𝐶
    d. 2𝐴𝐵 = 2𝐴𝐶


  2. What is the reason for the statement 𝐴𝐵 + 𝐵𝐶 = 𝐴𝐶 in Step 4?
    a. Line Addition Postulate
    b. Segment Addition Postulate
    c. Line Segment Addition
    d. Congruent Segment Addition


  3. What is the reason for the statement 𝐴𝐵 = 𝐵𝐶 in Step 6?
    a. Addition Property of Equality
    b. Subtraction Property of Equality
    c. Multiplication Property of Equality
    d. Division Property of Equality


Additional Activities

Directions: Write a proof for the situation given below. Write your answers on separate sheet of paper.

Walking down a hallway in the school, you notice that the library is halfway between the canteen and the Science laboratory. The Science laboratory is halfway between the library and the computer laboratory. Prove that the distance between the entrances of the canteen and library is the same as the distance between the entrances of the Science laboratory and computer laboratory.

Answer Key

Pre-Assessment
  1. C
  2. A
  3. B
  4. B
  5. C
  6. C
  7. C
  8. D
  9. C
  10. A
  11. D
  12. A
  13. A
  14. B
  15. D
What’s In
  1. 4
  2. 6
  3. 3
  4. any number except 0
  5. 7 + 5 = 10 + 2
What’s More
Activity 1: I Need Proof!
  1. Given
  2. 2𝑏 + 2 = −6
  3. Subtraction Property of Equality
  4. 2𝑏/2 = −8/2
  5. by Simplification
Activity 2: Prove Me Indirectly!
  1. B
  2. F
  3. C
  4. A.
  5. D.
  6. E
Activity 3: I Like to Prove It! Prove It
Direct Proof
StatementsReasons
1. (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) = 3Given
2. (1/5)𝑥 + (1/5)(10) = 3Distributive Property of Equality
3. (1/5)𝑥 + 2 = 3by Simplification
4. (1/5)𝑥 + 2 − 2 = 3 − 2Subtraction Property of Equality
5. (1/5)𝑥 = 1by Simplification
6. 5[(1/5)𝑥] = 5[1]Multiplication Property of Equality
7. 𝑥 = 5by Simplification
Indirect Proof

This is to prove that 𝑥 ≠ 5.

Situation 1: If 𝑥 > 5

StatementsReasons
1. 𝑥 > 5Given
2. 𝑥 + 10 > 5 + 10Addition Property of Inequality
3. 𝑥 + 10 > 15by Simplification
4. (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) > (1/5)(15)Multiplication Property of Inequality
5. (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) > 3by Simplification

This is a contradiction that (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) = 3. Therefore, 𝑥 = 5.

References

Abunzo, Emmanuel, et.al. Mathematics 8 Learner’s Module. Pasig City, Philippines: Book Media Press, Inc. and Prinwell, Inc., 2013.

Cecile M. De Leon, Soledad Jose-Dilao, Ed.D. and Julieta G. Bernabe (2002). Geometry: Textbook for Third Year, pp. 202-203. JTC Corporation 1281 Gregorio Araneta Avenue, Quezon City.

Diaz, Z.B., Mojica, M.P., Manalo, C.B., Suzara, J.L., Mercado, J.P., Esparrago, M.S., et.al (2017). Next Century Mathematics 8. Philippines. Phoenix Publishing House, Inc.

Assessment – Post
  1. D
  2. A
  3. D
  4. A
  5. C
  6. B
  7. B
  8. B
  9. B
  10. B
  11. B
  12. C
  13. C
  14. B
  15. B
Additional Activities

Answers may vary

Situation 2: If 𝑥 < 5

StatementsReasons
1. 𝑥 < 5Given
2. 𝑥 + 10 < 5 + 10Addition Property of Inequality
3. 𝑥 + 10 < 15by Simplification
4. (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) < (1/5)(15)Multiplication Property of Inequality
5. (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) < 3by Simplification

This is a contradiction that (1/5)(𝑥 + 10) = 3. Therefore, 𝑥 = 5.

What I Have Learned
Steps in Writing Direct ProofSteps in Writing Indirect Proof
1. Assume the statement 𝑝 is true.
2. Use what you know about 𝑝 and other facts as necessary to deduce that another statement 𝑞 is true, that is show 𝑝 → 𝑞 (if p then q) is true.
1. Identify the statement you want to prove. Assume temporarily that this statement is false by assuming that its opposite is true.
2. Reason logically until you reach a contradiction.
3. Point out that the desired conclusion must be true because the contradiction proves the temporary assumption false.
What I Can Do

Answers may vary.

21 CO_Q2_Mathematics8_ M14

For inquiries or feedback, please write or call:

Department of Education – Bureau of Learning Resources (DepEd-BLR)

Ground Floor, Bonifacio Bldg., DepEd Complex Meralco Avenue, Pasig City, Philippines 1600

Telefax: (632) 8634-1072; 8634-1054; 8631-4985

Email Address: blr.lrqad@deped.gov.ph * blr.lrpd@deped.gov.ph

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For students and teachers

Looking for a school?

Look up the enrollment, teachers, classrooms and facilities of more than 60,000 schools across the Philippines, from DepEd’s public data. Free to use.

Philippine Schools Directory by TeacherPH · every region, province, division and district