Reading and Writing Skills Quarter 4 Module 5: Critical Reading as Reasoning

Reading and Writing Skills Q4 Module 5 for Senior High School: identify assertions, formulate counterclaims, determine evidence, and use hedges.

This is the Senior High School self-learning module (SLM) for Reading and Writing Skills, Quarter 4, Module 5: Critical Reading as Reasoning. It was developed by DepEd Region 4A CALABARZON (First Edition, 2020) for learners who study at home. After working through it, learners should be able to read a text actively, judge how it builds its argument, and check whether its evidence holds up.

On this page 6 sections

What learners will learn

The module has one lesson, Lesson 1: Critical Reading as Reasoning. After going through it, the learner is expected to:

  1. identify assertions;
  2. formulate counterclaims; and
  3. determine evidence.

Key ideas: critical reading and reasoning

The lesson starts by connecting to the previous module on intertext and hypertext. It notes that hypertext reading is harder than intertext reading because of the information overload from the web, which the reader has to recognize and evaluate.

The module then defines two terms:

  • Critical reading is an analytic activity in which the reader asks questions about the text and the author’s claim. Critical readers evaluate, analyze, and interpret the author’s assertions and the hidden meaning of the whole text.
  • Reasoning, citing the Merriam-Webster dictionary, is the act of giving statements for justification and explanation. It is the ability to defend something by giving reasons.

When reading critically, you question the arguments the author uses, because any weak point can weaken the conclusion. The module stresses one point several times: critical reading is not meant to criticize but to assess the validity of textual evidence.

Three steps in critical reading as reasoning

The module presents these steps from Rodriguez and Tiongson’s book Reading and Writing Skills:

StepWhat it means
Identifying assertionsRecognize the common types of assertion: fact, convention, opinion, and preference.
Formulating counterclaimsA counterclaim is made to rebut a previous claim.
Determining evidenceEvidence is the details the author gives to support a claim.

The module uses an everyday example. You ask your father for an Android cellphone: that is your claim. He answers, “No, you can’t!” because you already have a phone: that is his counterclaim. To respond, you give your reason, for example that an Android phone would be useful for online classes in the new normal set-up.

Using hedges for a courteous tone

A counterclaim expresses an unfavorable statement, so the module advises using hedges, which are words or phrases that soften a statement and keep the tone courteous. The forms of hedges it lists are:

  • Modals: may, could, would, should, might, certain, must
  • Frequency adverbs: usually, generally, commonly
  • Probability adverbs: probably, possibly, presumably

Its example turns the plain statement “The common colds caused by a virus” into a hedged one: “The common colds must be caused by a virus.”

Activities in the module

  • What I Know: a 15-item multiple-choice pretest.
  • What’s New: a short paragraph about poverty and disasters in Eastern Samar, with a question on what the writer fails to consider.
  • What’s More: a passage about Crecencian T.V.L. senior high school graduates. Learners underline the claim, circle the evidence, and box the reasoning.
  • What I Have Learned: a reflection journal with two columns, “My takeaways from the lesson” and “How will I apply them in my everyday life?”
  • What I Can Do: “Let’s Talk,” where learners pick an editorial from a newspaper or the internet and analyze it with a dialogic journal. The guide questions ask about the issue, the writer’s stand, purpose, tone, assumptions about readers, and evidence.
  • Assessment: a 15-item multiple-choice post-test.
  • Additional Activities: learners write a paragraph on any topic using an outline (claim with supporting details, three pieces of text evidence, and a short counterclaim). A rubric weights claim at 60%, evidence at 30%, and argument at 10%.

How to use this module

For learners: Start with the pretest to see what you already know, then go through the parts in order: What’s In, What’s New, What is It, and the activities. Write all answers on a separate sheet of paper and do not mark the module. For What I Can Do, attach the editorial you chose to your answer sheet. Finish with the post-test and check your work honestly with the answer key.

For parents: Help your child find an editorial in a newspaper or online for the What I Can Do activity, and encourage them to ask the teacher when a task is unclear.

For teachers: The Notes to the Teacher suggest letting students choose their own article to read and analyze. The answer key at the end covers the pretest, What’s In, the post-test, and What’s More; review it before sharing, since some pretest answers appear misnumbered.

Frequently asked questions

What grade and quarter is this module for?

It is a Senior High School module for Reading and Writing Skills, Quarter 4, Module 5. The module does not name a specific grade.

What are the steps in critical reading as reasoning?

The module gives three steps: identifying assertions (fact, convention, opinion, and preference), formulating counterclaims to rebut a previous claim, and determining the evidence the author gives to support a claim.

What are hedges and why are they used?

Hedges are words or phrases that soften a statement so a counterclaim sounds courteous. The module lists modals such as may and could, frequency adverbs such as usually, and probability adverbs such as probably.

Is critical reading the same as criticizing?

No. The module states that critical reading is not meant to criticize but to assess the validity of textual evidence.

Does the module have an answer key?

Yes. It includes answers for the pretest, What’s In, the post-test, and the What’s More passage, though some pretest answers appear misnumbered.

Full text of the module

The text below is a transcription of the PDF above, as printed.

Senior High School

Reading and Writing Skills Quarter 4 – Module 5: Critical Reading as Reasoning

[illustration: students reading outdoors under a tree and at a desk, a teacher helping students, a globe, and a child working by lamplight]

Reading and Writing Skills Alternative Delivery Mode Quarter 4 – Module 5: Critical Reading as Reasoning First Edition, 2020

Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things, impose as a condition the payment of royalties.

Borrowed materials (i.e., songs, stories, poems, pictures, photos, brand names, trademarks, etc.) included in this module are owned by their respective copyright holders. Every effort has been exerted to locate and seek permission to use these materials from their respective copyright owners. The publisher and authors do not represent nor claim ownership over them.

Published by the Department of Education Secretary: Leonor Magtolis Briones Undersecretary: Diosdado M. San Antonio

Printed in the Philippines by _____

Department of Education – Region 4A CALABARZON

Office Address: Gate 2 Karangalan Village, Brgy. San Isidro, Cainta, Rizal Telefax: 02-8682-5773/8684-4914/8647-7487 E-mail Address: lrmd.calabarzon@deped.gov.ph

Development Team of the Module

Writer: Rosalina C. Castañeda

Editors: Orven Francis G. De Pedro and Susana J. Sacatrapos

Reviewers: Rex D. Bibal, Reina Czarina L. Fule, Ferdinand R. Castillo and Mariel Jewel F. Silva

Illustrators: Jayson K. Latade and Romdel F. Partoza

Layout Artists: Victoria P. Gabiano and Romdel F. Partoza

Management Team: Francis Cesar B. Bringas, Job S. Zape, Jr., Ramonito Elumbaring, Reicon C. Condes, Elaine T. Balaogan, Fe M. Ong-ongowan, Daisy Z. Miranda, Vincent Emmanuel L. Ilagan, Henry P. Contemplacion, Laila R. Maloles

Reading and Writing Skills Quarter 4 – Module 5: Critical Reading as Reasoning

Senior High School

Introductory Message

This Self-Learning Module (SLM) is prepared so that you, our dear learners, can continue your studies and learn while at home. Activities, questions, directions, exercises, and discussions are carefully stated for you to understand each lesson.

Each SLM is composed of different parts. Each part shall guide you step-by-step as you discover and understand the lesson prepared for you.

Pre-tests are provided to measure your prior knowledge on lessons in each SLM. This will tell you if you need to proceed on completing this module or if you need to ask your facilitator or your teacher’s assistance for better understanding of the lesson. At the end of each module, you need to answer the post-test to self-check your learning. Answer keys are provided for each activity and test. We trust that you will be honest in using these.

In addition to the material in the main text, Notes to the Teacher are also provided to our facilitators and parents for strategies and reminders on how they can best help you on your home-based learning.

Please use this module with care. Do not put unnecessary marks on any part of this SLM. Use a separate sheet of paper in answering the exercises and tests. And read the instructions carefully before performing each task.

If you have any questions in using this SLM or any difficulty in answering the tasks in this module, do not hesitate to consult your teacher or facilitator.

Thank you.

What I Need to Know

[illustration: hand pressing a button]

This module enhances the student’s knowledge regarding critical reading as reasoning. It will help the learner be able to interact with the text, formulate judgment on how the text works and assess the validity of textual evidence.

The module discusses one lesson namely;

  • Lesson 1- Critical Reading as Reasoning

After going through this module, the learner is expected to:

  1. identify assertions;
  2. formulate counterclaim; and
  3. determine evidence.

What I Know

[illustration: hand holding a pencil]

Choose the letter of the best answer. Write the chosen letter on a separate sheet of paper.

  1. Fact, convention, opinion, preference are common types of assertion used in


    A. Identifying assertion
    B. Formulating counterclaim
    C. Determining evidences
    D. None of the above


  2. Critical reading is not to criticize but to assess the validity of the text


    A. True
    B. False
    C. Both A & B
    D. None of the above


  3. Determining evidences is


    A. Asserting facts to support claims
    B. Rebutting a previous claim
    C. Conducting a survey
    D. Showing courteous


  4. Hedges are used to be courteous in expressing


    A. Evidence
    B. Assertions
    C. Counterclaims
    D. Critical reading


  5. Hypertext reading is more difficult than intertext reading.


    A. True
    B. False
    C. Both A & B
    D. None of the above


  6. Your tone must be courteous when you are writing counterclaims.


    A. True
    B. False
    C. Both A & B
    D. None of the above


  7. It is the act of giving statement for justification and explanation.


    A. Hedges
    B. Reasoning
    C. Asserting
    D. Evidence


  8. It is an engaging in analytic activity which involves the reader by asking questions about the text and the author’s claim.


    A. Evidence
    B. Assertions
    C. Counterclaims
    D. Critical reading


  9. Interaction with the text is NOT necessary in evaluating judgment.


    A. True
    B. False
    C. Both A & B
    D. None of the above


  10. The following are the forms of hedges, EXCEPT:


    A. Modals
    B. Frequency adverbs
    C. Location adverbs
    D. Probability adverbs


  11. Which is an example of a modal hedge?


    A. Could
    B. Probably
    C. Usually
    D. None of the above


  12. Which is an example of a probability adverb?


    A. Could
    B. Probably
    C. Usually
    D. None of the above


  13. Which is a Frequency adverb?


    A. Could
    B. Probably
    C. Usually
    D. None of the above


  14. It is a body of facts given by the authors to support their claims?


    A. Counterclaims
    B. Opinion
    C. Evidence
    D. None of the above


  15. Critical reading is meant to assess the validity of textual evidence and not criticize.


    A. True
    B. False
    C. Both A & B
    D. None of the above


Lesson 1 Explain critical reading as reasoning

Interaction with the text is very important to the reader because it will make you evaluate and formulate judgment on how the text works.

In this lesson, it will focus on explaining critical reading as reasoning.

What’s In

Previously you have learned the different functions of intertext and hypertext. Hypertext reading is more difficult than intertext reading because of information overload taken from the web, wherein the reader needs to recognize and evaluate it.

Now let’s move on in explaining critical reading as reasoning.

Notes to the Teacher

The teacher may let the students choose their article to be read and analyze.

What’s New

Read the paragraph and answer the following question on a separate sheet.

Eastern Samar is an underdeveloped place and is one of the most disaster-prone places in the Philippines. Because of poverty, residents are forced to live in high-risk place, which makes them prone to disasters. Disasters in Eastern Samar affect a large number of people by destroying their houses, farmlands, livelihoods, and other personal assets.

Question What issue is given focus by the writer makes to support the conclusion about the relation of poverty to disaster?

  • a. The writer fails to consider the role of poverty in causing disasters.
  • b. The writer concludes that the situation in Eastern Samar will generalize to all underdeveloped places.
  • c. The writer fails to consider the role of disaster play in causing poverty.
  • d. The writer fails to explain how people are affected by a disaster
What is It

Critical reading is engaging in analytic activity which involves the reader by asking questions about the text and the author’s claim. Critical readers are doing the process of evaluating, analyzing, and interpreting the assertion of the hidden meaning of the whole text.

While reasoning as defined by Merriam Webster dictionary is an act of giving statements for justification and explanation. It is the ability of someone to defend something by giving out reasons.

Therefore, when reading critically, it is necessary to question the different arguments used by the author, as any problem can weaken the authenticity of the conclusion.

Remember that Critical reading is not meant to criticize but to assess the validity of textual evidence.

Steps Used in Critical Reading As Reasoning

by Maxine Rafaella C. Rodriguez and Marella Therese A. Tiongson

  1. Identifying assertions


    Identify by a common type of assertion such as fact, convention, opinion and preference


  2. Formulating counterclaim


    Counterclaims are made to rebut a previous claim


  3. Determining evidence


    Evidence is the details given by the authors to support his/her claims


Example

You are asking your father for an android cellphone, that is your claim. Then your father answers you. “No, you can’t!” this is his counterclaim. He might say that you already have a cellphone.

Therefore when you are going to formulate reason for the counterclaim, you should state the reason why you are asking for an android cellphone. You might say that you could use it in your online classes because Android cellphone would be very useful in this new normal classroom set-up.

When you write your counterclaim, you are expressing unfavorable statements. Therefore it is needed to use hedges words or phrases to be able to give a courteous tone.

Different forms of hedges Modals: may, could, would, should, might, certain, must, etc. Frequency adverbs: usually, generally, commonly Probability adverbs: probably, possibly, presumably

Example: The common colds caused by a virus.

With hedges: The common colds must be caused by a virus. The common virus is certain to be caused by a virus.

What’s More

Read the passage carefully. Underline the claim, circle the evidence, and box the reasoning that you can find in the passage. Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper.

Crecencian T.V.L. senior high school graduates are capable of joining the workforce and being globally competitive skilled workers since passing the National Competency II examination is the result of the in-depth training that they had developed while in school. Crecencian T.V.L instructors are highly skilled in their field of specialization. They are NC III & IV holders and have years of experience in the industry before joining the academe. Many of the skilled graduates are now hired by different corporations and some of them continue their college education in connection with their chosen strand.

What I Have Learned

Get your reflection journal then write down your takeaways from the lesson and their impact on your skill to think critically. Use the template as your guide.

My takeaways from the lessonHow will I apply them in my everyday life?
What I Can Do

Let’s Talk; this activity aims to make conversation between the student and the author of the text. This inspires the learner to challenge claims in a conversational manner. However, the learner should have an in depth study of the resources used in the text

Find an editorial article either from the newspaper or internet then try to evaluate and analyze the text. Use the given Dialogic journal template with guided questions. Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper. Please attach the chosen article on your answer sheet.

Before reading the article ask yourself the following questions:

  1. Why are you reading the article?
  2. What do you hope to learn as you read it?

Name: _____ Date: _____

Title: _____

Author of the article: _____

Question/sParagraph & page no.Answer/s with supporting detail/s
What issue is given focus by the writer?
Is the writer able to take a clear stand on is issue?
What is the writer’s purpose writing the article?
What is the writer’s tone? Why?
Does the writer’s assume the readers to agree with his /her stand?
What are the evidence presented by the writer to support his argument?

Assessment

Multiple Choice. Choose the letter of the best answer. Write the chosen letter on a separate sheet of paper.

  1. Which is an example of a probability adverb?

    • A. Could
    • B. Probably
    • C. Usually
    • D. None of the above
  2. Fact, convention, opinion, preference are common types of assertion used in

    • A. Identifying assertion
    • B. Formulating counterclaim
    • C. Determining evidences
    • D. None of the above
  3. Determining evidences is

    • A. Asserting facts to support claims
    • B. Rebutting a previous claim
    • C. Conducting a survey
    • D. Showing courteous
  4. Hedges are used to be courteous in expressing

    • A. Evidence
    • B. Assertions
    • C. Counterclaims
    • D. Critical reading
  5. Critical reading is not to criticize but to assess the validity of the text

    • A. True
    • B. False
    • C. Both A & B
    • D. None of the above
  6. Hypertext reading is more difficult than intertext reading.

    • A. True
    • B. False
    • C. Both A & B
    • D. None of the above
  7. Your tone must be courteous when you are writing counterclaims.

    • A. True
    • B. False
    • C. Both A & B
    • D. None of the above
  8. Critical reading is meant to assess the validity of textual evidence and not criticize.

    • A. True
    • B. False
    • C. Both A & B
    • D. None of the above
  9. Interaction with the text is NOT necessary in evaluating judgment.

    • A. True
    • B. False
    • C. Both A & B
    • D. None of the above
  10. Which is an example of a modal hedge?

    • A. Could
    • B. Probably
    • C. Usually
    • D. None of the above
  11. Which is a Frequency adverb?

    • A. Could
    • B. Probably
    • C. Usually
    • D. None of the above
  12. It is a body of facts given by the authors to support their claims?

    • A. Counterclaims
    • B. Opinion
    • C. Evidence
    • D. None of the above
  13. It is the act of giving statement for justification and explanation.

    • A. Hedges
    • B. Reasoning
    • C. Asserting
    • D. Evidence
  14. The following are the forms of hedges, EXCEPT:

    • A. Modals
    • B. Frequency adverbs
    • C. Location adverbs
    • D. Probability adverbs
  15. It is an engaging in analytic activity which involves the reader by asking questions about the text and the author’s claim.

    • A. Evidence
    • B. Assertions
    • C. Counterclaims
    • D. Critical reading
Additional Activities

Write a paragraph with any topic that interests you. Use the outline as your guide.

I. What is your claim?

  • A. Supporting detail
  • B. Supporting detail

II. Write three lines or different text evidences that support your argument.

  • A.
  • B.
  • C.

III. Write a short counterclaim or counter-argument to the claim

Rubric

Sufficient claimInsufficient claimScore
I. Claim (60%)
II. Evidence (30%)
III. Argument (10%)
Total (100%)

Answer Key

What I Know

[transcriber’s note: item 1 of this column is not printed in the image]

  1. A
  2. A
  3. C
  4. C
  5. A
  6. A
  7. B
  8. D
  9. B
  10. C
  11. A
  12. B
  13. C
  14. C
  15. A
What’s In
  1. B
Assessment
  1. B
  2. A
  3. C
  4. C
  5. A
  6. A
  7. A
  8. A
  9. B
  10. A
  11. C
  12. C
  13. B
  14. C
  15. D
What’s More

[transcriber’s note: the text is printed upside down in the image. Colors as printed: “evidence/green”, “claim/red (circle)”, “Blue (underline)”, “reasoning – (box)”.]

Crecencian T.V.L. senior high school graduates are capable to join the workforce. Through the in depth training that they had developed in school after they passed the National Competency II examination. Crecencian T.V.L instructors are highly skilled in their field of specialization. They are NC III & IV holders and have years of experience in the industry before joining the academe. In addition many of the skilled graduates are now hired by different corporations and some of them continue their college education in connection with their chosen strand.

References

Book

Rodriguez ,Maxine Rafaella C. and Tiongson, Marella Therese A., Reading and Writing Skills, Manila, Rex Book Store, Inc, 2016.

For inquiries or feedback, please write or call:

Department of Education – Bureau of Learning Resources (DepEd-BLR)

Ground Floor, Bonifacio Bldg., DepEd Complex Meralco Avenue, Pasig City, Philippines 1600

Telefax: (632) 8634-1072; 8634-1054; 8631-4985

Email Address: blr.lrqad@deped.gov.ph * blr.lrpd@deped.gov.ph

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For students and teachers

Looking for a school?

Look up the enrollment, teachers, classrooms and facilities of more than 60,000 schools across the Philippines, from DepEd’s public data. Free to use.

Philippine Schools Directory by TeacherPH · every region, province, division and district