This is the Science Grade 10 Self-Learning Module for Quarter 3, Module 6: Evidence of Evolution. It is the First Edition (2020) from the Department of Education Region I, written for learners studying at home or in class. It explains what evolution means in biology and how scientists use fossils, body structures, embryos, and genetic information to show that species change over time.
On this page 6 sections
What learners will learn
After going through this module, learners should be able to:
- Explain how fossil records, comparative anatomy, and genetic information provide evidence for evolution (S10LT-IIIf-39)
- Compare homologous, analogous, and vestigial structures and analyze their significance in evolutionary history
- Identify the effect of gene mutation on the evolution of the species
What is inside the module
The module has one lesson, “Evidence of Evolution,” arranged in the usual self-learning module parts:
- What I Know: a 15-item multiple-choice pretest.
- What’s In: a fill-in-the-letters review of terms (myth, creationism, fossils, catastrophism, uniformitarianism) and a matching activity on early scientists and their theories.
- What’s New: “I Can See You!”, where learners compare skulls and leg bones of the horse’s ancestors, from Eohippus (dawn horse) to Equus (modern horse).
- What is It: the main discussion of the evidence for evolution.
- What’s More: five activities on limb bones, wings, vestigial structures, embryos, and evolution versus creationism.
- What I Have Learned: a fill-in-the-blanks summary.
- What I Can Do: a short written response to the claim “Man originated from apes.”
- Assessment: a 15-item multiple-choice post-test.
- Additional Activities: a vocabulary activity on ten evolution terms.
- Answer Key and a reasoning rubric for written answers.
Key ideas: the evidence for evolution
The module teaches that evolution is not just change over time. Biological evolution involves change passed on through genetic inheritance, and it shows that life on Earth shares a common ancestor, the way you and your cousin share a grandparent. Charles Darwin proposed that new species descend from an ancestor. Today the main evidence comes from the fossil record, embryology, comparative anatomy, and molecular biology.
Direct and indirect evidence
- Direct evidence can be observed or seen. Fossils are the main example.
- Indirect evidence does not involve actually watching evolution happen, but lets us infer that change took place. Examples are homologous, analogous, and vestigial structures, embryology, and biogeography.
Fossils and the geological time scale
Fossils are the remains of organisms from long ago. They usually form when an organism is covered by sediments that harden into rock, and also when organisms are buried in volcanic ash or trapped in tar or tree sap. When fossils are arranged by age, scientists can compare body structures and see that species are not fixed. The fossil record is incomplete, though, because few organisms fossilize and only where conditions are right. The module uses the fossil of Archaeopteryx, an early bird, as an example.
The module also traces when groups appeared on the geological time scale: fishes first, then amphibians, reptiles, and finally mammals and birds. Among plants, bryophytes came before vascular plants, and angiosperms (flowering plants) appeared in the Cretaceous period.
Comparative anatomy
| Type of structure | Meaning | Examples from the module |
|---|---|---|
| Homologous | Similar embryonic origin, even if the function differs | A bird’s wing and a frog’s foreleg; forelimbs of humans, whales, cats, bats, and birds |
| Analogous | Same function, but different origin and build | Wings of birds and flies; moth and bat wings; butterfly and bird wings |
| Vestigial | Reduced structures that have lost their function | The human appendix; the pelvic bones and reduced hind legs of snakes; the missing eyes of cave fish |
Homologous structures suggest an evolutionary link between species.
Embryology and genetic evidence
Related organisms look alike in early embryo stages. Human embryos have folds in the neck called pharyngeal pouches, which become gills in some animals; in humans they develop into muscles for eating and facial expression, glands in the neck, and middle ear bones. The module also notes that DNA testing shows about 98 percent genetic similarity between humans and chimpanzees, which points to a shared ancestry.
Scientists and theories reviewed
- Georges Cuvier: catastrophism
- James Hutton and Charles Lyell: uniformitarianism
- Jean-Baptiste de Lamarck: theory of acquired characteristics
- Charles Darwin: theory of natural selection
The summary also mentions other mechanisms of evolution (non-random mating, gene flow, genetic drift, and mutations) and two types of speciation: allopatric (a population split by a geographic barrier) and sympatric (split without a physical barrier).
How to use this module
- Learners: Take the pretest first. If you get all 15 items right, you may skip the module; if you score 14 or below, go through it. Work through the parts in order, write your answers on a separate sheet with your name, and check the answer key only after finishing the whole module, including the post-test. You may answer in English or a mix of your vernacular and English.
- Parents: Help your child keep a steady pace and remind them to use the answer key honestly, after finishing.
- Teachers: The Notes to the Teacher say the module has brief but substantial concepts with enrichment activities and assessments, and the teacher assists and guides learners. Use the reasoning rubric (claim, explanation, reasoning) to score open-ended answers such as Activity 5 and the What I Can Do task.
Frequently asked questions
What grade and quarter is this Evidence of Evolution module for?
It is for Grade 10 Science, Quarter 3, Module 6.
Does the module have an answer key?
Yes. It has answers for the pretest, the post-test, and the activities, plus a reasoning rubric for written responses. Learners are asked to check it only after finishing the whole module.
What is the difference between homologous and analogous structures?
Homologous structures share a similar embryonic origin even if their functions differ, like a bird’s wing and a frog’s foreleg. Analogous structures do the same job but have different origins, like the wings of birds and flies.
Why are fossils called direct evidence of evolution?
Fossils can be directly observed, and when arranged by age they show how body structures changed over time. Indirect evidence, such as homologous structures and embryology, lets scientists infer that evolution happened.
Can learners skip the module?
The module says learners who answer all 15 pretest items correctly may skip it. Those who score 14 or below should go through the module.
Full text of the module
The text below is a transcription of the PDF above, as printed.
Science Quarter 3 – Module 6: Evidence of Evolution
CO_Q3_Science 10_ Module 6
Science – Grade 10 Alternative Delivery Mode Quarter 3 – Module 6: Evidence of Evolution First Edition, 2020
Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things, impose as a condition the payment of royalties.
Borrowed materials (i.e., songs, stories, poems, pictures, photos, brand names, trademarks, etc.) included in this module are owned by their respective copyright holders. Every effort has been exerted to locate and seek permission to use these materials from their respective copyright owners. The publisher and authors do not represent nor claim ownership over them.
Published by the Department of Education Secretary: Leonor Magtolis Briones Undersecretary: Diosdado M. San Antonio
Printed in the Philippines by ________________________
Department of Education – Region I Office Address: Flores St., Catbangen, City of San Fernando, La Union Telefax: (072) 682-2324; (072) 607-8137 E-mail Address: region1@deped.gov.ph
Development Team of the Module
Writers: Flornelove R. Opinano, Michelle C. Regala Editors: Gloria I. Pernes, Arlene A. Abiang, Annabelle M. Parel, Ritchie G. Macalanda Reviewers: Jaime D. Campos, Jr., Gina A. Amoyen, Editha T. Giron, Evangeline A. Cabacungan Illustrator: Robinson A. Bayson, Emhil C. Mendrano, Marcelo Johnn H. Lagonoy Layout Artist: Francis Henry P. Palaruan, Jecson L. Oafallas Management Team: Tolentino G. Aquino, Arlene A. Niro, Cornelio R. Aquino, Gina A. Amoyen, Maybelene C. Bautista, Editha Giron, Julie G. De Guzman
Science Quarter 3 – Module 6: Evidence of Evolution
Introductory Message
This Self-Learning Module (SLM) is prepared so that you, our dear learners, can continue your studies and learn while at home. Activities, questions, directions, exercises, and discussions are carefully stated for you to understand each lesson.
Each SLM is composed of different parts. Each part shall guide you step-by-step as you discover and understand the lesson prepared for you.
Pre-tests are provided to measure your prior knowledge of lessons in each SLM. This will tell you if you need to proceed with completing this module or if you need to ask your facilitator or your teacher’s assistance for a better understanding of the lesson. At the end of each module, you need to answer the post-test to self-check your learning. Answer keys are provided for each activity and test. We trust that you will be honest in using these.
In addition to the material in the main text, Notes to the Teacher are also provided to our facilitators and parents for strategies and reminders on how they can best help you on your home-based learning.
Please use this module with care. Do not put unnecessary marks on any part of this SLM. Use a separate sheet of paper in answering the exercises and tests. And read the instructions carefully before performing each task.
If you have any questions in using this SLM or any difficulty in answering the tasks in this module, do not hesitate to consult your teacher or facilitator.
Thank you.
What I Need to Know
I Evolve, You Evolve, and They Evolve!
You may have met the term “evolve” in some popular comic series or video games and somehow developed an idea of what the word means. In this module, we will find out its meaning in biology and its role in tracing species’ development.
Some organisms may look the same but have distinct differences from each other, others may not be related to each another, but they have similar functional features and characteristics. Some animals before are very different from the animals we have now.
This module will take you on a historic voyage that has changed our view of the history of life. Come and join in this exploration and discover what Charles Darwin and other scientists have written about how species evolve with time!
After going through this module, you should be able to:
- Explain how fossil records, comparative anatomy, and genetic information provide evidence for evolution (S10LT-IIIf-39);
- Compare homologous, analogous, and vestigial structures and analyze their significance in evolutionary history; and
- Identify the effect of gene mutation on the evolution of the species.
Before going on, check how much you know about this topic. Answer the pretest on the next page in a separate sheet of paper.
Going through this module can be a meaningful learning experience. All you need to do is make use of your time and resources efficiently. To do this, here are some tips for you:
- Take the pre-test before reading the rest of the module.
- Take time to read and understand the lesson. Follow instructions carefully. Do all activities diligently. This module is designed for independent or self-paced study. It is better to be slow but sure than to hurry and miss the concepts you are supposed to learn.
- Always use a clean sheet of paper for your answers in the activities or assessments. Don’t forget to write your name and label them appropriately.
- Try to recall and connect the ideas about the Earth that you had in the lower years. Use the concept discussed in the lesson to explain the results of activities or performance tasks. You may answer in English or a
combination of your vernacular and English.
- Be honest. When doing the exercises, record what you have observed. Take the self-assessment after each activity, but do not turn to the Answer Key page unless you are done with the entire module.
- Don’t hesitate to ask. If you need to clarify something, approach or contact your teacher or any knowledgeable person to help you. You may also look into other references for further information. There is a list of references at the back part of this module.
- Take the post-test prepared at the end of the module to assess how much you have learned from this module.
- You can check your answers in the activities, self-assessments, and post-test after finishing the entire module to know how much you have gained from the lesson and the activities.
Before you study this module, let’s check how much you know about this topic. An answer key is provided at the end of the module. But do not try to look at it while answering. You can check your answer after you are done with the pre-test.
What I Know
Multiple Choice. Write the letter of the best answer on your sheet of paper
Where can most fossils be found?
a. Black soil
b. Lava flows
c. Granite rock
d. Sedimentary rockThe following statements describe evolution EXCEPT
a. Evolution is continuous.
b. Evolution refers to change.
c. The world is stable and unchanging.
d. The mutation causes evolution only when it becomes heritable.In what era are the oldest fossils located?
a. Mesozoic
b. Cenozoic
c. Paleozoic
d. Pre CambrianWhich of the statements best describes the Theory of Natural Selection?
a. Acquired characteristics of parents can be passed on to offspring.
b. Organisms develop desirable structures to survive in a given environment.
c. Organs that are not used may disappear, while organs that are constantly utilized may develop.
d. In nature, the organisms with desirable characteristics may survive, while those with weaker traits may not.Which idea best describes the theory of evolution?
a. Earth is relatively young.
b. Each organism is specially created
c. Species are related by common descent.
d. A mix of fossils in a region indicates that a local catastrophe occurred.An adaptation promotes ______________________________.
a. chance to survive
b. chance to reproduce
c. chance to survive and reproduce
d. None of the aboveVertebrate forelimbs are most likely to be studied in ___________________.
a. Ecology
b. Embryology
c. Biogeography
d. Comparative anatomyAll of these are true about fossils EXCEPT?
a. They indicate that life has a history.
b. They are pieces of evidence of life in the past.
c. The older the fossils, the less they resemble modern-day species.
d. They look precisely like modern-day species, regardless of their age.Which is accurate about the description of homologous structures?
a. Structures are similar in origin and structure. They evolve to fit the animal’s way of life.
b. Structure in different organisms that serve the same function. They show no evolutionary relationship between organisms.
c. Structure that functions and later on disappear
d. All of the aboveNatural selection states that ______________________.
a. nature selects the variations within a species that are most useful for survival.
b. fitness is an organism’s ability to survive and produce fertile offspring.
c. a change in a species occurs over time
d. all of the aboveThe criterion used to determine if an organism is a new species is based on _____
a. time
b. geography
c. reproduction
d. physical traitsWhich of the following statements does NOT describe Darwin’s theory of natural selection?
a. Members of a population will compete.
b. Populations tend to reproduce in small numbers.
c. Members of a population have heritable variations.
d. Some members of a population have adaptive traits.Which of the following describes indirect pieces of evidence for evolution?
a. It is observed or seen
b. It involves actual observations
c. It is something that does not involve actual observation of evolution but for which we can infer that change has taken place
d. None of the above.The strongest evidence of evolution from a common ancestor is ________
a. similar embryological structures.
b. similar DNA sequences.
c. similar body structures.
d. similar fossils.What does it mean by direct evidence for evolution?
a. It consists of observations of actual evolution
b. It does not involve direct observation of the evolution
c. It is something that is not observed or seen
d. None of the above.
How did you find the pretest? What was your score? If you got 15 items correctly, you may skip the module. But if your score is 14 and below, you must proceed with the module.
Have fun learning!
Lesson 1: Evidence of Evolution
Evolution is not just a matter of change over time. Many things evolve such trees lose their leaves, mountain ranges rise and erode, but they aren’t examples of biological evolution since they don’t involve through genetic inheritance.
The central idea of evolution is that life on Earth shares a mutual ancestor, as you and your cousin share a common grandparent.
Through the development with change, the common ancestor of life on Earth pave way to the fantastic diversity that we see documented in the fossil record and around us today. Evolution means that we’re all distant cousins: humans and oak trees, hummingbirds and whales.
What’s In
Activity 1 – What Am I
Fill up the missing letters to identify a term related to Origins of Evolution.
| Definition | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1 | MY _ _ | Refers to ancient story or set of stories, especially explaining the early history of a group of people. |
| 2 | CRE_TIONI_M | Held the idea that all forms of life were evolved in their present form by a divine being, and they remain unchanged from the beginning. |
| 3 | FO_SI_S | Any preserved remains impression or trace of any once-living thing from a past geological age. |
| 4 | CATA_TRO_HISM | The doctrine that sudden catastrophes, rather than continuous change, cause the main features of the Earth’s crust |
| 5 | UN_FORMI_ARIANISM | It is a geological theory that describes the processes shaping the Earth and the Universe. It states that changes in the Earth’s crust throughout history have resulted from uniform, continuous functions that are still occurring today. |
Activity 2
Match It Down: Match column A with the correct answer on column B, write only the letter of response on the blank provided in the test paper. You may choose an option in column B twice.
| Column A | Column B |
|---|---|
| _____1. Georges Cuvier | A. Theory of Acquired characteristics |
| _____2. James Hutton | B. Theory of Natural Selection |
| _____3. Jean Baptiste de Lamarck | C. Theory of Catastrophism |
| _____4. Charles Darwin | D. Theory of Uniformitarianism |
| _____5. Charles Lyell |
Notes to the Teacher
This module contains brief but substantial concepts of Evidence of Evolution. Enrichment activities and assessments for the learners are provided.
The teacher will assist and guide the learners while going through this module.
What’s New
Activity 1 – I CAN SEE YOU!
I. Material: Activity sheet
II. Procedure: The figure below is a series of skulls and front leg fossils of organisms believed to be the modern-day horse’s ancestors—answer the following Guide Questions based on the figure. Please be guided by the labeled figures below.
[chart: labeled diagram; Lateral View of the Skull and Front leg of Horse]
Labels on the skull: Bony orbit; Temporoman dibular joint [transcriber’s note: the word “Temporomandibular” is split across two lines in the original]; Maxillary cheek teeth; Wolf tooth; Canine tooth; Incisor tooth; Mandibular cheek teeth; Mandible.
Labels on the front leg: Knee; Superficial Digital Flexor Tendon; Pastern; Hoof Wall; Deep Digital Flexor Tendon; Coffin.
Lateral View of the Skull and Front leg of Horse (Illustrated by Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
[chart: diagram; Modern Day Horse Evolution; (Illustrated by Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)]
Labels: Eohippus (Dawn horse); Mesohippus; Merychippus; Pliohippus; Equus sp. Modern day horse; HIND FOOT; FORE FOOT.
Modern Day Horse Evolution (Illustrated by Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
III. Guide Questions:
- Give atleast two resemblances between each of the skulls that might conclude that these are all related species.
- What is the most significant change in skull anatomy from the dawn horse to the modern horse?
- What is the most significant change in leg anatomy from the dawn horse to the modern horse?
What is It
Evidence of Evolution
Evolution is not a historical process; it occurs at this moment. Populations constantly adapt to variations in their environment and thereby gather changes in the genes that are existing to the species through its gene pool.
Charles Darwin proposed the idea that all new species descend from an ancestor. Thus, he performed an exhaustive amount of research to provide as much evidence as possible. Today, the significant evidence for this theory is the fossil record, embryology, comparative anatomy, and molecular biology.
Evidence to support the theory of evolution comes from different fields of science. However, pieces of evidence of evolution are divided into two groups: direct and indirect. Direct evidence can be directly observed or seen, such as fossil evidence. On the other hand, indirect evidence does not involve actual observation of evolution. We can conclude that evolution has taken place such of homologous, analogous, and vestigial structures, embryology, and biogeography.
Geological Time Scale and Evolution of Animals and Plants
Giovanni Avduina developed the first geological time scale. The oldness of the Earth is about 4600 million years. Life first initiated in water (3600 million years ago). The history of the Earth has been separated into several major divisions called eras. The modern periods are divided into epochs.
The origin of vertebrates took place in the Ordovician period in ostracoderms (jawless vertebrates related to cyclostomes). Ostracoderms were small, jawless bony fish-like forms. After the ostracoderms, acanthodians (the earliest known vertebrates with lower jaws) appeared in the Silurian period. Placoderms (the ancient gnathostomes- jawed vertebrates) also emerged in the Silurian period. Also, the origin of amphibians occurred in the Devonian period. Reptiles appeared in the Carboniferous period. The origin of dinosaurs and mammals took place in the Triassic period. Toothed birds (first birds) appeared in the Jurassic Period. Thus, fishes’ origin took place first, with amphibians next, followed by reptiles, then mammals and birds.
Different kinds of algae were present in the Cambrian period. Marine algae were abundant in the Ordovician period. The origin of bryophytes took place before vascular plants’ appearance (pteridophytes, gymnosperms, and angiosperms). The origin of vascular plants took place in the Silurian period. First gymnosperms appeared in the Devonian period. The origin of the first seed plants occurred in the Carboniferous period. Angiosperms appeared in the Cretaceous period. Angiosperms diversified in the Miocene, and their adaptive radiation occurred in the Pliocene.
PART 1: EVIDENCE OF FOSSIL
Fossils are the remnants of an creature from the primitive times. Most organisms do not fossilize, and geological processes usually destroy those that do, or they never surface for examination. Fossils are generally formed when an organism is covered by sediments that then harden into sandstone, slate, mudstone, or flint. Organisms also fossilize when buried in volcanic ash or entombed in tar or tree sap.
According to experts, fossil provides direct evidence for evolution because it can tell what has happened. By simply studying fossils occurring in different strata of rocks, geologists can reconstruct evolutionary change time and course. It can show that variation in time has happened. When fossils are set in the order of how old they are, we can directly compare their body structures. Through these, fossils’ experts can confirm that species are not fixed but can evolve into other species over time.
Experts have difficulty interpreting fossil evidence because the fossil record is relatively incomplete since a small number of fossils are found. Moreover, the remains of organisms are preserved only in places where the condition is favorable.
[chart: illustration; Figure 2 Fossil Identification Based on their Method of Formation; (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)]
Figure 2 Fossil Identification Based on their Method of Formation (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
[illustration: fossil of an Archaeopteryx bird with wings spread]
Figure 3 Fossil of Archaeopteryx Bird (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
PART II: COMPARATIVE ANATOMY
A. Homologous and Analogous Structure
The discipline of comparative anatomy is vital in understanding relationships among creatures. Structures are classified to be homologous if they have similar embryonic origins and analogous if they are identical only in function. For instance, birds’ and flies’ wings are examples of comparable structures in which they serve the same function but have different embryonic origins (one is made of bone and flesh, the other is mainly composed of non-living chitin). On the other hand, birds’ wings and the foreleg of a frog are considered homologous structures (though limbs have different functions, their embryonic origins are alike). For some comparative anatomists, homologous structures are important because they imply an
evolutionary linkage between two species. However, comparing the anatomy and the development of organisms reveals a unity of plan among those strictly connected. The more species have the same functions in terms of body, the nearer they are related.
[illustration: bone structures of four different limbs of vertebrates]
Figure 4 Showing the Difference between Homologous Structures of Different Species (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
[illustration: moth wing and bat wing]
MOTH
BAT WING
Figure 5 Showing Analogous Structure of Different Species (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
B. Vestigial Structure
Gradual changes have occurred through time that has, in some cases, reduced or removed the function of somebody’s organs and structure. The human’s appendix that is reduced and no longer digests rough vegetation (Figure 5) and pelvic bones of snakes with reduced hind legs (Figure 6) are examples of this phenomenon. Moreover, vestigial structures are structures that have gone their function in the organism and have become reduced in size (because of efficiency).
[transcriber’s note: the text cites Figure 5 for the appendix and Figure 6 for the snake, but the printed figure captions are Figure 6 (human digestive system) and Figure 7 (snake pelvic bone); the citations are reproduced as printed]
[illustration: human digestive system showing the appendix]
Figure 6 Human Digestive System showing the appendix (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
[illustration: pelvic bone of a snake with a label reading “Reduced hind legs”]
Reduced hind legs
Figure 7 Pelvic bone of a Snake showing a reduced hind limb (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
PART III: EMBRYOLOGY
A study of organism’s embryonic progress provides further clues to its evolutionary past. Scientists proclaimed that “ontogeny summarizes phylogeny.” Simply means that this theory proposes that if a certain organism undergo its embryonic development (ontogeny), it duplicates (recapitulates) the stages in its evolutionary history (phylogeny). For example, during your development, human folds in the neck area are referred to as pharyngeal pouches, which in some animals become gills. This notion of embryology as an “instant replay” of evolution has been called the biogenetic law.
Although the connection between evolution and embryonic development is more complex than once thought, related organisms do show similarities in their embryonic development (see figure 5). These resemblances can be traced to the conservative nature of embryology: small changes on the early development can have severe significances in advanced phases concluded a “domino” effect. Gills are not found in adult humans therefore all vertebrates have comparable pouches from which they ascend. For humans, these pharyngeal pouches go on to develop muscles for eating and facial appearance, endocrine glands in the neck and bones of the middle ear. From an evolutionary perspective, many people believe similarities in embryology are valuable because they reveal our kinship with other phylum members.
[illustration: early embryonic stages of fish, salamander, tortoise, chick, pig, calf, rabbit and human, arranged in rows, labeled FISH, SALAMANDER, TORTOISE, CHICK, PIG, CALF, RABBIT, HUMAN]
Figure 8. Early Embryonic Stages of the Different Vertebrates showing Similar Embryonic Structures Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy
What’s More
Here are some enrichment activities for you to work on to master and strengthen the basic concepts you have learned from this lesson.
Activity 1 – TAKE MY HANDS!
Shown below are images of the skeletal assembly of the front appendages of six animals:, whale, crocodile, cat, bird, human and bat. Each animal has a similar set of bones. Color code each of the bones according to this key:
- Humerus [blue ]
- Ulna [red ]
- Radius [green]
- Carpals [black]
- Metacarpals [orange]
- Phalanges [brown]
[illustration: series of vertebrate embryos at their most advanced stage, labeled Fish, Salamander, Tortoise, Chick, Rabbit, Human]
Figure 8.B Series of Vertebrate Embryos at their Most Advanced Stage (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
Assessment 1: For each animal, indicate what type of movement each limb is responsible for.
[illustration: skeletal structures of the front limbs of human, whale, lizard, bird, cat and bat, labeled HUMERUS, RADIUS, ULNA, CARPAL, METACARPAL, PHALANGES, HUMAN, WHALE, LIZARD, BIRD, CAT, BAT]
Figure 9: Images of the Skeletal Structure of the Front Limbs of Different Animals (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
Assessment 1: For each animal, indicate what type of movement each limb is responsible for.
| Animal | Primary Functions |
|---|---|
| Human | Using tools, picking up and holding objects |
| Whale | |
| Cat | |
| Bat | |
| Bird | |
| Crocodile |
Activity 2: On the WINGS of Evolution!
Direction: Compare the anatomy of the butterfly and bird wing below.
[illustration: butterfly wing and bird wing, labeled BUTTERFLY WING and BIRD WING]
Figure 10 Comparative Anatomy of the Butterfly and Bird’s wing (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
Guide Questions:
- What is the function of each structures?
- How are they different in form? Give specific differences.
Activity 3: VESTIGIAL: Look What Is Missing?
Direction: Compare the cave fish’s overall body structure (Phreatichthys andruzzii) and the minnow (Phoxinus phoxinus) below.
[illustration: cave fish and minnow fish body structures]
Figure 11 Body Structure of Cave Fish and Minnow Fish (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
Guide Questions:
- What is the most apparent difference between the body structure of these two fish?
- Assume two fish came from the same original ancestor. Why might the cavefish have evolved without eyesight?
- What kind of sensory variation would you hypothesize if the cavefish has to allow it to direct in a cave, including catching and ingestion of food?
Activity 4: THE BIRTH OF THE EMBRYO!
Direction: Closely related organisms may have physical resemblances before they are born. Take a look at the 6 different structure of the embryos below:
[illustration: series of six vertebrate embryos labeled A to F, older and more developed embryos from the same organisms]
Figure 12 Series of vertebrate embryos in Older and More Developed Embryos from the same Organisms. (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
[illustration: series of six vertebrate embryos labeled A to F at the early stage]
Figure 13 Series of vertebrate embryos at the Early Stage (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
Table 1. Hypothesize which embryo is from each of the following organisms. Write the letter only.
| Species | Embryo |
|---|---|
| Human | |
| Chicken | |
| Rabbit | |
| Tortoise | |
| Salamander | |
| Fish |
Table 2
| Species | Embryo |
|---|---|
| Human | |
| Chicken | |
| Rabbit | |
| Tortoise | |
| Salamander | |
| Fish |
Direction: Describe how the embryos changed for each of these organisms from their earliest to the latest stages based on the figures shown above. (The first item is given as an example)
[illustration: series of vertebrate embryos at their most advanced stage, shortly before birth, labeled Fish, Salamander, Tortoise, Chick, Rabbit, Human]
Figure 14 Series of Vertebrate Embryos at their Most Advanced Stage, shortly Before Birth (Illustrated by: Marcelo John V. Lagonoy)
| Species | Anatomical Changes from Early to Late Stages |
|---|---|
| Human | Example: Developed limbs, external ears, a large head, and a nose |
| Chicken | |
| Rabbit | |
| Tortoise | |
| Salamander | |
| Fish |
Guide Questions:
- Look at the six embryos in their earliest stage. Describe the patterns you observed. What physical similarities exist among the embryos?
- Does this suggest an evolutionary relationship among the organisms? Explain how embryos can be used as indication of common ancestor among these six organisms.
Activity 5 – CREATION TO RESURRECTION: A MYSTERY OF HISTORY
Creationism believes that a higher power created the animals and everything that exists today through supernatural intervention. Religious beliefs, such as creationism, are accepted based on faith and cannot be tested or investigated. While evolution is a slow process in which something changes into a different and usually more complex or better-adapted form.
Conflicts between Evolution and Creationism happen when evolutionists claim that creationism is not a scientific theory because it cannot be verified by the scientific method. In contrast, creationists argue that evolutionists do not take God into account and that evolution is just a theory rather than a fact.
Science requires that a hypothesis or theory must be maintained by physical indication, whereas religion involves acceptance of a doctrine without analysis.
DNA testing has prove that humans and chimpanzees have a 98-percent genetic similarity, having an devastating indication that apes and humans have a shared ancestry. Scientists are willing to take these outcomes as indication that man is a specific type of ape, but this is what creationists find most revolting since they believe that “God created man in his image,” as stated in Genesis 1:27.
For this reason, struggles between evolution and creationism have never been resolved.
Guide Questions:
- Based on the statement given above, give your insight into how science influences man’s traditional origin.
- Do you think science ‘disproves’ the Law of Bible which refers to the Creation of the man based on God’s image? Why?
- In what ways are scientific concepts about creation different from these creation myths? How are creation myths similar to scientific theories?
Great job! You have understood the lesson. Are you now ready to summarize?
What I Have Learned
What are the things that you have learned from this module?
- _____ is the idea that a divine being creates living things and remains unchanged since the beginning.
- _____ is the idea that forceful and sudden natural disasters have give rise to extinction due to death of organisms. After each disaster, God created new sets of life forms.
- _____ is the person who believed that the environment could bring about inherited change.
- _____ proposed the theory of evolution through natural selection. He believed that all organisms originate from a common ancestor.
- Evidence for evolution come from many sources. Evidence is classified as direct and indirect. _____ evidence means something that can be obviously observed or seen. Fossils provide direct evidence for evolution. _____ evidence is something that does not include actual observation of evolution but for which we can infer that evolution has taken place.
- Similar structures in different species irrespective of their functions are called _____ structures. _____ structures are those that has the same function though possibly in very different ways. _____ structures are structural features present in organism but have no function.
- _____ is not the only driving force for evolution to occur, other mechanisms include non-random mating, gene flow, genetic drift, and mutations.
- Two types of speciation are identified: allopatric and sympatric. _____ speciation happens when a population is divided into two by a geographic barrier. In _____ speciation, a population is split into two or more in the absence of physical barriers.
What I Can Do
Self-Test
A friend says to you, “Man Originated from Apes” because many physical and biochemical resemblances are found between them. How would you react to this?
Assessment
Multiple Choice. Write the letter of the best answer on your sheet of paper.
An adaptation promotes ______________________________.
A. chance to survive
B. chance to reproduce
C. chance to survive and reproduce
D. None of the aboveThe criterion used to determine if an organism is a new species is based on _________________.
A. time
B. geography
C. reproduction
D. physical traitsWhere can most fossils be found?
A. Black soil
B. Lava flows
C. Granite rock
D. Sedimentary rockVertebrate forelimbs are most likely to be discussed in ___________________.
A. Ecology
B. Embryology
C. Biogeography
D. Comparative anatomyWhich of the following statements does NOT describe Darwin’s theory of natural selection?
A. The members of a population of the organisms will strive.
B. Populations tend to replicate in minimal numbers.
C. Members of a population have genetic differences.
D. Some members of a inhabitants have adaptive behaviors.The following statements describe evolution EXCEPT
A. Evolution is continuous
B. Evolution refers to a change
C. The world is stable and unchanging
D. The mutation causes evolution only when it becomes heritableAll of these are true about fossils EXCEPT?
A. They specify that life has a history.
B. They are evidence of the ancient life.
C. The older fossils may look like less than the modern day species.
D. They look precisely like modern-day species, regardless of their age.Which of the following describes indirect evidence for evolution?
A. It is observed or seen
B. It involves actual observations
C. It is something that does not involve actual observation of evolution but for which we can infer that evolution has taken place
D. None of the above.In what era do the oldest fossils locate?
A. Mesozoic
B. Cenozoic
C. Paleozoic
D. Pre CambrianWhat best defines homologous structures?
A. Structures are similar in origin and structure. They evolve to fit the animal’s way of life.
B. Structure in different organisms that serve the same function. They show no evolutionary relationship between organisms
C. Structure that functions and later on disappear
D. All of the aboveNatural selection states that
A. nature selects the variations within a species that are most useful for survival.
B. fitness gives organisms the ability to survive but not to produce fertile offspring.
C. a change in a species occurs over time
D. all of the aboveWhich of the following statements best describes the Theory of Natural Selection?
A. Developed characteristics of parents can be passed on to offspring.
B. Organisms develop necessary structures to survive in a given environment.
C. Organs that are not used may fade, while organs that are constantly utilized may develop.
D. In nature, the organism with necessary characteristics may survive, while those with weaker traits may not.The most obvious evidence for evolution from a common ancestor is ________
A. similar embryological structures.
B. similar DNA sequences.
C. similar body structures.
D. similar fossilsWhat does it mean by direct indication or evidence for evolution?
A. It consists of observations of actual evolution
B. It does not involve direct observation of the evolution
C. It is something that is not observed or seen
D. None of the above.Which idea best describes the theory of evolution?
A. Earth is comparatively young.
B. Each organism is specially shaped
C. Species are related by common ancestry.
D. A mix of fossils indicates that a local catastrophe occurred.
Great job! You are almost done with this module.
Additional Activities
Activity 1 – KNOW ME
Fill up the missing letters to identify a term related to evolution.
| Definition | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1 | S_EC_A_ION | the formation of new and distinct species in the course of evolution |
| 2 | BI_GEO_RA_HY | study of the distributions of organisms |
| 3 | EM_RY__OGY | The study of the prenatal development of the gametes, fertilization, and development of embryos and fetuses |
| 4 | V_ST_GI_L | an anatomical feature or behavior that no longer seem to have a purpose in the current form of an organism of the given species. |
| 5 | O_GA_IS_ | Refers to an individual cretaures such as a, animal, plant or a single-celled life form. |
| 6 | A_ALO_O_S | are structures that are different in appearance but have the same function |
| 7 | H_MOL_GO_S | alike structures in different species irrespective of their functions |
| 8 | A_AP_AT_ON | set of genetically developed traits that make the organism better suited to its environment. |
| 9 | S_E_I_S | creatures that can replicate with one another in nature and produce fertile offspring |
| 10 | O_FS_RI_G | young born of living organisms that produced either by a single organism or, in the case of sexual reproduction, two organisms. |
Answer Key
[transcriber’s note: this page is printed rotated 180 degrees; the answer boxes and tables are read in upright order]
Assessment
- C
- C
- D
- D
- B
- C
- D
- C
- D
- A
- A
- D
- B
- A
- C
What I Know
- D
- C
- D
- D
- C
- C
- D
- D
- C
- A
- C
- B
- C
- B
- A
What’s In (Activity 1)
- MYTH
- CREATIONISM
- FOSSILS
- CATASTROPHISM
- UNIFORMITARIANISM
What’s In (Activity 2)
- C
- D
- A
- B
- D
What’s New
Activity 1
Guide Questions
- The skulls all have a similar ridge that protrudes from the top. The overall shape is the same. Each skull has a set of flattened teeth. Each skull has a large diastema, or gap between the front and back teeth.
- The size of the skull is dramatically larger in the modern horse.
- The modern horse, in addition to having longer legs, has developed hooves in place of hand/foot bones.
What’s More
Assessment 1
| Animal | Primary Functions |
|---|---|
| Human | Using tools, picking up and holding objects |
| Whale | Swimming. |
| Cat | Running, jumping, pouncing, climbing, catching prey. |
| Bat | Flying, gliding. |
| Bird | Flying, gliding. |
| Crocodile | Swimming, walking. |
Lesson Activities
[transcriber’s note: this page is printed rotated 180 degrees; read in upright order]
Activity 2
- Flight.
- The bird’s wing is constructed of bone, muscle, skin, and feathers. The butterfly’s wing is a thin membrane of exoskeleton inflated by blood.
Activity 3
- The cave fish does not have any eyes.
- As the name suggests, cave fish lives in caves that are completely devoid of sunlight. In this environment, developing eyes would not grant any evolutionary advantage.
- The cave fish has special sense organs on its body surface that respond to the presence of different chemicals in the water. This would be analogous to our sense of smell.
Activity 4
A.
| Species | Embryo |
|---|---|
| Human | F |
| Chicken | D |
| Rabbit | E |
| Tortoise | C |
| Salamander | B |
| Fish | A |
[transcriber’s note: a second table with the same columns and letters is printed beside the first]
| Species | Embryo |
|---|---|
| Human | F |
| Chicken | D |
| Rabbit | E |
| Tortoise | C |
| Salamander | B |
| Fish | A |
B.
| Species | Anatomical Changes from Early to Late Stages |
|---|---|
| Human | Developed limbs, external ears, a large head, and a nose. |
| Chicken | Developed a beak, larger eyes, four limbs including wings, and a short tail. |
| Rabbit | Developed four limbs, external ears, a mouth, nose, and a tail. |
| Tortoise | Developed a shell, long tail, larger eyes, and a beak. |
| Salamander | Developed external gills, four limbs, and a long tail. |
| Fish | Developed internal gills and a full set of fins for swimming. |
Guide Questions:
- Each of the embryos has the same basic shape, including a tail. They all have external segmentation where the backbone will eventually develop. They also all have gill slits, even the animals that will eventually develop lungs.
- The similarities between these embryos, especially at their early stages, are striking. While each of these animals has a unique adult body structure, they all seem to have emerged from the same early blueprint. This suggests a common ancestor between all these vertebrates. These observations are probably not random coincidence.
Activity 5
- ANSWERS MAY VARY
- The answer depends on how a person defines “mental gymnastics” as well as how literally a person takes the Genesis creation account. If a person takes Genesis completely literally, then science is not compatible. Science refutes that the world was formed in six days. Genesis states that explicitly. If one is willing to view each with a grain of salt, however, one could fit science and Genesis together rather easily for the most part.
- If viewed purely as the story of Earth, Genesis still fits with science if taken with a grain of salt. Before the Sun, the Earth could be something other than a “void,” there needed to be light, in this case the Sun. The Earth would also have begun rotating as soon as it sprung into existence, hence the separation of night and day. One could also argue that the earth mentioned was not actually Earth specifically, much as how modern people do not always mean the entire universe when they say “the universe” or may use “the world” to refer to all of existence, not just the little sliver that exists on Earth. In this case, “earth” could potentially stand in for the Cosmic Egg which would make Genesis match science more closely.
REASONING RUBRICS
| 2 points | 1 point | 0 point | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim An assertion that is something true | Makes a claim that is sufficient to answer the question and is coherent | Makes a claim that is sufficient to answer the question of coherent | Does not make a claim or makes an incoherent claim |
| Explanation Describes how and why a phenomenon occurs | Provides an explanation that addresses how and why a phenomenon occurs | Provides an answer that addresses how or why a phenomenon occurs | It does not offer an explanation |
| Reasoning Provides reason the reader should accept your claim or explanation | Includes all of the following: ✓ Cites sufficient and relevant evidence to support the claim and explanations ✓ Describe how the cited evidence defends the claim/explanation. | Includes one of the following ✓ Cites sufficient and relevant evidence to support the claim and explanations ✓ Describe how the cited evidence defends the claim/explanation. | Includes none of the following ✓ Cites sufficient and relevant evidence to support the claim and explanations ✓ Describe how the cited evidence defends the claim/explanation. |
What I Have Learned
- Creationism
- Catastrophism
- Jean Baptist Lamarck
- Charles Darwin
- Direct, Indirect
- Homologous, Analogous
- Natural Selection
- Allopatric, Sympatric
Additional Activities
- SPECIATION
- BIOGEOGRAPHY
- EMBRYOLOGY
- VESTIGIAL
- ORGANISM
- ANALOGOUS
- HOMOLOGOUS
- ADAPTATION
- SPECIES
- OFFSPRING
References
Website
Department of Education. “K to 12 Curriculum Guide (Science 3 to 10). Accessed November 2019: https://www.deped.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Science-CG_with-tagged-sci-equipment
LDRMS Portal. Project EASE. Biology. http://lrmds.depedldn.com/DOWNLOAD/BIOLOGY_M15_EVOLUTION.PDF
LRDMS Portal. General Biology II 12 Q1M5: The Development of Evolutionary Relationships: Tree of Life and Systematics. Accessed November 13, 2020
LDRMS Portal. General Biology II 12 Q1M3.2: The Development of Evolutionary Thought. Accessed February 16, 2020
LRDMS Portal. Science Modules. December 29, 2014. Accessed Octiber 13, 2019: https://lrmds.deped.gov.ph/detail/7574
For inquiries or feedback, please write or call:
Department of Education – Bureau of Learning Resources (DepEd-BLR)
Ground Floor, Bonifacio Bldg., DepEd Complex Meralco Avenue, Pasig City, Philippines 1600
Telefax: (632) 8634-1072; 8634-1054; 8631-4985
Email Address: blr.lrqad@deped.gov.ph * blr.lrpd@deped.gov.ph
Leave a Reply